Talk About All That Stuff About TV Shows!

It’s Game Over for the Hi-Res Hype

PostIt’s Game Over for the Hi-Res Hype by RubberJonny

This article, from John Watkinson, author of The MPEG Handbook, is a really interesting read about how the way we view TV and film currently has nothing to do with the way in which we physically perceive moving pictures.
What is actually on the screen doesn’t move. It is a series of still pictures that are each held there for a short while before being replaced. Currently, the obsession is for ever higher pixel counts, an approach that disregards how we actually see moving images.

Intuitively, you would think that the frame rate - the number of pictures per second - would have quite a large bearing on the quality of the illusion, and you would be right. Equally, you might think that the film and TV companies had done a lot of research into human vision in order to choose those rates that have been in use unchanged for decades. Unfortunately, you would be wrong.

Let’s see how we arrived at the current frame rate of movie film: 24fps. Silent movies ran even slower, at 18fps, but when the optical soundtrack was invented, it was found that the sound was too muffled at the old film speed because the optics couldn’t resolve the higher pitches in the soundtrack. So the film was sped up in order to get enough sound quality. The use of 24fps in movies has nothing whatsoever to do with any study of human vision.

American television runs at 60 fields per second, whereas in the old world we get along with 50. Do Americans have better vision than Europeans so they need a higher rate? Fact is, the rates used in television were chosen to be the same as the frequency of the local electricity supply because of fears that different rates might interfere or beat with electric light. Once more, the decision had nothing to do with human vision. The entire edifice of film and TV picture rates has no foundation and it is going to have to change.
If and when companies do take real notice of the need for change i can't wait to see what is produced!

Peace Out!
Jonny!
Man Will Never Be Free Until The Last King Is Strangled With The Entrails Of The Last Priest
User avatar
RubberJonny
 
7 years of membership7 years of membership7 years of membership7 years of membership7 years of membership7 years of membership7 years of membership
User Details: Show details
National Flag:
Great Britain
» Thu Jun 27, 2013 2:37 pm «Top